7 Reasons To Change The National Anthem
Most nations sing about values, their history and achievements or of the beauty of the land .... yet we are supposed to sing about an unelected head of state. It is time to change the national anthem!
9/28/20251 min read
Our national anthem is about asking a God most of us no longer believe in to save an unelected billionaire who does not pay his taxes.
Many British people advocate for changing the national anthem, "God Save the King" (or "God Save the Queen"), for various reasons. These typically fall into cultural, political, and historical categories. Here are the key reasons:
1. Lack of Inclusivity
- The anthem focuses heavily on the monarchy and its preservation, which does not represent the diversity and democratic principles of modern Britain.
- Republicans are excluded.
2. Outdated and Monarchical Focus
- "God Save the King" is deeply tied to the monarchy, an outdated institution.
- A national anthem should represent the people, their values, and the nation as a whole, rather than a single family or figure.
3. Regional Concerns
- In Scotland, Wales, and Northern Ireland, some people view the anthem as symbolic of English dominance rather than British unity.
4. Desire for a Modern, Secular Anthem
- We highlight the religious tone of the anthem, which appeals to divine intervention for the monarch. In an increasingly secular society, this feels out of step with contemporary Britain.
- A new anthem could focus on themes like liberty, equality, and unity, which would resonate more broadly.
5. Association with Colonial History
- The anthem's historical ties to British imperialism and colonialism can evoke negative feelings for those critical of Britain’s colonial past.
- A new anthem could represent a break from this legacy, fostering a more inclusive image.
6. Melodic and Emotional Appeal
- Critics of the anthem also point out that the melody and lyrics lack the rousing, inspiring qualities seen in other national anthems, like France's "La Marseillaise" or the United States' "The Star-Spangled Banner."
- A modern anthem could be more musically engaging and emotionally uplifting.
7. Inspiration from Other Nations
- Countries like South Africa and Germany have revised or changed their national anthems to reflect new values and unite citizens after significant historical shifts. Some British people see this as a model for change.
What Alternatives Are Suggested?
- "Land of Hope and Glory": A patriotic song with strong historical associations.
- A completely new composition reflecting contemporary Britain.
Conclusion
The anthem does not represent the values, diversity, and identity of modern Britain. The debate reflects broader discussions about the nation's future, its institutions, and its place in the world.