A Tale Of Two Catherines

Two women named Catherine stand in the public eye today — Catherine Connolly, President of Ireland, and Catherine Middleton, Princess of Wales. Their lives, however, could not be more different. One comes from decades of sustained political struggle, grassroots activism, and hard-won respect. The other entered public prominence largely through marriage into one of the world’s most famous royal families.

Looking at their stories side by side reveals a stark contrast in opportunity, privilege, and the kind of work required to reach national visibility.

Catherine Connolly: The Product of Determination, Grit, and Relentless Work

Catherine Connolly’s rise is a study in perseverance.

Born in Galway to a large working family, Connolly carved her own path through education, social advocacy, and public service. Nothing about her ascent came easily or automatically:

-She put herself through advanced education, earning a master’s in clinical psychology and later a law degree, both of which required years of intense personal effort.

-She began at the local level of Irish politics, knocking on doors, attending community meetings, and representing people long before national media ever noticed her.

-In 2020, she broke barriers as the first woman to serve as Leas-Cheann Comhairle, a role earned through parliamentary respect, not family connections.

-She spent decades championing causes that were not always popular: neutrality, housing, equality, the Irish language, environmental protection, and the rights of marginalised groups.

Nothing in Connolly’s career was delivered to her. She built it step by step, from the ground up, often working against a political establishment that did not expect — or always welcome — her success.

Her presidency is the culmination of a life defined by serious work, principled stands, and persistence in the face of political inertia.

Catherine Middleton: A Life Shaped by Access, Opportunity, and a Royal Marriage

Catherine Middleton’s path, by contrast, has been shaped by privilege, access, and a level of public elevation that comes with royalty rather than political struggle.

Though she grew up outside the aristocracy, she still benefited from:

-A comfortable, well-resourced upbringing that afforded private schooling and elite social environments.

-Attendance at the University of St Andrews, an institution whose social circles regularly intersect with wealth and influence.

-Meeting William at university — the pivotal moment that placed her on a trajectory toward becoming Duchess of Cambridge and later Princess of Wales.

Her public role, duties, and influence derive not from elected service, community organising, or a grassroots political journey, but from her marriage into the royal family, which instantly granted global visibility, institutional support, and a platform of influence most people — including Connolly — spend a lifetime working toward.

Two Paths, Two Worlds

Connolly’s path

-Built on decades of political work

-Entirely self-made

-Marked by constant campaigning, criticism, and uphill battles

-Achievements earned through democratic process, dedication, and steadfast vision

Middleton’s path

-Shaped by privilege and elite environments

-Elevated by marriage to a future monarch

-Public role granted, not competed for

-Influence derived from tradition and status, not elected mandate

What Their Stories Reveal

These two women illustrate two fundamentally different realities:

-One shows what a determined individual can achieve without privilege, relying on intellect, perseverance, and conviction.

-The other shows how proximity to power can instantly create a platform that millions of hardworking people will never have access to.

Both Catherines are public figures. But only one had to fight her way there, every step of the journey.

Greens For A Republic members are working hard with and for all the Catherine Connollys of this world.

Feeling inspired? Email the Policy Development Committee at pdc@greenparty.org.uk

Any Green Party member can join a Policy Working Group. Help us shape a democratic future!